Magnanimous Gesture
“A fine portrait indeed, sir. And so your ancestor Roderick would have won, but for a magnanimous gesture?”
“It would appear so. He had drawn first blood and the matter might have ended there–should have ended there.”
“But the challenger would not hear of it?”
“That’s right. Suddenly he proclaimed it a fight to the death. Roderick had no such wish or intent. He had only accepted the challenge as a gesture to satisfy the older man’s sense of honor and now here was that same man, wounded and yet still determined to shed the blood of his rival.” De Bere leaned over and filled the other man’s glass.
“This is an excellent claret.”
“It is from my own vineyards–an exceptional year. I’m glad you approve, Racine.”
“So Roderick lost the fight but retained the vineyard?”
“By no means. He did not lose the fight.”
“But you said he did not prevail.”
“Nor did he. He tried reason, to persuade his foe that there were less… final ways of settling their dispute. He even put up his sword. But the other man attacked him from behind.”
“From behind, you say?”
“Precisely. Hardly the actions of a gentleman.”
“Quite so. But in that case he must surely lose the fight.”
“Ah, but that is the meat of the tale. The fates intervened.”
“How so?”
De Bere leaned forward, clearly animated by the story. “I have heard it told so many times and still it thrills me in the retelling. Roderick tripped on a vine root before the stroke fell. The challenger stumbled and fell over him as he lunged forward in his murderous vehemence, and all at once the sword flew from the blackguard’s hand, upward into the air and, as he lay winded on the ground, it pierced his own deceitful heart. No vine has grown since, where he fell. The soil bears a black stain. I can show you the place.” He drank deeply.
“No need. I have seen it.”
“You have the advantage of me, sir?”
“I thank you for your hospitality but now I think it is time to finish what our great grand-cestors started.”
“What?” De Bere stood to his feet.
“You never utter the name of the man who brought that righteous and justified challenge ’gainst Roderick De Bere. Perhaps you do not know it?”
“It has been considered bad luck in our family for three generations to pronounce the name of… of…”
“Augustine Malevola? The name dropped like bad blood between them.”
“And you?”
“His great grandson, Justice Malevola Racine, oh yes. The fight was not over a woman, as you have been taught. Nor was Augustine the person who attacked from behind. It was all done for land. It was for the disputed vineyards and for settling an age-old family rift that went farther back than even these two could remember.”
De Bere began to be afraid. He had no weapon, no wish to fight and even less wish to die. “You said you come… to finish this?”
“Yes. I bear you no personal grudge. I see no reason for us to be enemies just because our ancestors were greedy and foolish men. I have my own rank and standing. I need no other’s.”
DeBere breathed again.
“Only this I ask; that you no longer perpetuate this story–this lie. Augustine Malevola was a good man–a family man with a loving wife who mourned him deeply though she never knew his fate, for he was buried here, where he was murdered.”
“I…”
“Yes, murdered. But we shall say no more about it if you will agree to this.”
“The story, truth or not, will die with me.”
“Then let us just drink a toast in this good wine: to new formed friendships and old disputes laid to rest.”
De Bere filled the glasses and such was his relief that he did not he notice Malevola’s sleight of hand, nor the bitter taste of death.
